Showing posts with label science fair. Show all posts
Showing posts with label science fair. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

The science lab notebook

Science is really nothing if you can't describe what is happening and what you did to make it happen. All good scientist should keep a lab notebook full of their experiments. It also acts as a diary or journal about all the fun things you did and saw!

J is a little too young to keep one all by himself, but I want lab notebook keeping seem like an easy thing. I also found a super cute composition notebook for under $1 while stocking up for school supplies a year ago. J was thrilled for his new, ice cream covered science notebook.


I introduced the concept to him on the day we planted our garden and did our water density and floating egg experiment. I did the writing, but as I was writing, I was asking him questions and having him fill in the blanks. I drew some diagrams too, and he completed the drawings.

Parts of the notebook:

Front cover: I learned the hard way, after my lab notebook disappeared for a week, that you always want to put your name and if it's really important to you, a telephone number in case someone else finds it. Luckily, my notebook was placed on a ladder in the lab while I was distracted by impromptu visitors. Once found, my name and cell # immediately went on it.

Table of contents: I think for little kids, you're okay skipping this, unless you want a quick way to find what experiments you conducted. Leave a page or two blank in the front of the book and fill out the table of contents as you go. If you do a table of contents, I'd highly recommend numbering your experiment pages as you go.

Experiment pages: Follow the description below for each experiment. Some experiments will be much more elaborate or detailed than others. Some will be very simple. Work with your kid on a format that works for you. I like to ask J a lot of questions to see what he thinks as we go. I write his answers to my questions.

Generalities for notebook keeping: Always write in pen so your entries cannot be altered by you or someone else (falsifying information is never okay as a scientist). If you make a mistake, do not use whiteout or black it out with a marker. A single line through with your initials and date and the correct information written nearby will work. On professional notebooks, you want to sign and date every page. If it's important, like you are inventing something, you also want someone else to sign as a witness. Also, it is important to be neat. If you can't read and interpret your work, how will anybody else know what's going on?

For each experiment follow the format below:

Really, at a young age, simple is better. Here's the example page I worked on with J:


Date and Name of the Experiment

Introduction/Scientific Question: Why do you think what we're doing is important?

Hypothesis: What do you think is going to happen?

Materials and Methods: What did you use to do the experiment? How did you do the experiment? Drawings or pictures of how your experiment looked as it was set-up is very useful in this section.

Results: What happened? Drawings and graphs/charts are useful here too. On the graphics above, I drew the cups, and J drew the eggs (circles).

Discussion: Why did that happen? Was it what you expected/guessed/hypothesized? Can you explain why or why not? Do you have more questions posed by the results of your experiment? What can you do differently next time?

I hope you enjoyed this introduction to scientific notebook keeping. It's now a fun part of our science activities. J asks for his special science notebook all of the time.

Related post:
*Setting up a science fair display.

Sunday, February 3, 2013

Colored Celery Sticks

This colored celery experiment has been on my pinterest list for a long time. I finally decided to buy some celery, and we had some free time last weekend to try a 24 hr experiment. I also consulted this celery experiment for toddlers post our experiment to see their results.

Basic take home message:

Plants need water and use it during photosynthesis (plants need water and light to grow). We can see how the plants take in the water if we use colored water. It also turns the celery different, cool colors!

The experimental set-up:

We decided on 3 colors for the celery experiment: yellow, red, and blue. We filled the cups 3/4 full and used 4-5 drops per color.


J was a great helper.


We also at the last minute decided to add a control, which is something we can use to compare the other celery sticks to when the experiment is over. This celery stick had just water with no food coloring. We only had a small celery stick left at this point.


Hypothesis:

Big J and I asked J to guess what was going to happen. He had no idea why we colored the water, and his hypothesis had nothing to do with the colors. He did guess that the water was going to go down.

I thought that was a great hypothesis, and I wanted to make sure that J was able to see if he was right. You can barely see it in the beginning, but we used a dry erase marker on the cups to mark just above the water line (it's green on the yellow cup). The dry erase markers washed off in the end, in case you are worried.


Methods continued:

The experiment I pinned on pinterest ended up waiting 24 hrs, but we weren't seeing great results. We documented results at 24 hrs and 48 hrs.

Results, aka what happened:

At 24 hours we were able to see blue spots on the celery in blue water.


Our celery in red had a scratch on it. The scratch turned red and you could see the water leaking out, but there were no colors on the leaves at 24 hrs.


After 2 days (48 hrs), we extracted (took out) all of the celery sticks from the water. Here they are from left to right, no color, yellow, blue, red:


The control (no color) ended up looking healthier after 2 days. It was the smallest and weakest looking celery stick at the beginning. Yellow didn't really have anything to report on. You could see a little yellow in the celery veins leading up to the leaves, but there were no spots on the leaves.

Blue was our favorite. Here's a close-up of a leaf with blue spots and a blue vein behind it, so neat:


Red also gave us some interesting results. Here's a close-up of minor red spots:


And I (carefully) dissected the celery stick to get a better picture of the innards of the celery:


As for J's hypothesis:

All of the colors of water went down. J hypothesis was correct! We didn't compare which one went down more than others, maybe next time. Looking at the pictures from the experiment, there was no super visible difference between the three colors.


Note, that I took the celery out. The height of the water was slightly higher with the celery stick in it, but it was definitely visibly lower than the initial height of the water.

Potential problems with our experiment:

We didn't put the celery sticks in direct light (no space for it in our small apartment). Maybe if we repeat this experiment, I can clear out a space next to the windows.

For older kids:

Definitely don't forget the control. Preferably, your control will look like your other celery before you start. It would make for better comparisons when the experiment is over.

Dissect (cut apart) your results and document everything you see.

Repeat the experiment in different places. Try a dark closet, a window sill, and normal room lighting.

Try different plants. This site says carnations also work.

Monday, October 22, 2012

Water surface tension - pennies in a cup

Note: We got the idea for this experiment from Science Play book by Jill Frankel Hauser.

I grew up with a scientist mom, and her favorite experiment was the drops of water on a penny to analyze surface tension of water. That's a little too hard for my 3 year old to do (I remember being somewhere around 7 for those experiments). So when I found the experiment with placing pennies in a cup of water, I figured it would work for J.

Now, being a scientist myself, I had questions of my own that weren't answered by the book, like how does temperature affect surface tension of water? I decided that could be our experiment.

To complete the experiment, I filled up clear plastic glasses with different temperature water (cold water from our fridge, cold water from the sink, hot water from the sink - ours comes out really hot!) almost to the top of the glass. While the glass was on the table, I used a clean medicine dropper to fill the glass to the brim. We started gently adding pennies, one at a time waiting for the water surface to be calm before we placed another one on there.

The set-up

Water careful filled to the brim

The adults showed J how to do it.


J was so excited to do it himself, but three year olds aren't super careful and like when things splash.


Gently add pennies 1 by 1

In general: as temperature increases, surface tension should decrease (making it harder to stick together). Our hypothesis (educated guess) was that the colder glasses of water would hold more pennies.

Our results:

Cold glass: 26 pennies (J)
Room temp glass: 25 pennies (Big J)
Hot glass: 18 pennies (Mommy)

Things to discuss:
*What shape does the water make after adding pennies?
*How many pennies did you get into the cup before it spilled?
*How did the temperature affect the surface tension in your experiment?
*Which cup of water held the most pennies?
*Repeat the experiment with different liquids (ex. juice or isopropyl (rubbing) alcohol -under extremely close adult supervision). How do the different liquids act when the pennies are placed in them? Why do you think that is?

Things that could have affected our results:
*Cups might not have been filled to the same levels.
*We didn't place the pennies in gently enough, causing a splash.
*Pennies weren't fully dry between cups (adding more water).
*Someone could have accidentally bumped the table (it happens with a three year old).
*Pennies had various amounts of dirt on them. A piece of grass ended up in the cold cup, which could have affected the experiment.
*Each person did pennies in a different glass. Ideally, we would repeat the experiment with the same user for all three glasses, but we're not that patient around here and everyone wanted a turn.

Happy experimenting!

Tuesday, March 6, 2012

The Scientific Method

It's Science Fair time around our neck of the woods (hoods?).

As I've said before, I despised science growing up.  I really despised the requirement to do Science Fair on top of our crazy busy schedules.  You see, for us, science fair was only a high school requirement and only for those in honors level science courses - those college bound students who were already trying to do everything to get into college.  My first year I only needed to do a scientific proposal.  I don't remember what I did my second year for the experiment (pretty sure it sucked), and my third, I ended up winning the first place in my category (botany) at the district level.  I grew alfalfa sprouts under different colored lights (cellophane).  Nowadays, I dabble a lot in the scientific method through being a researcher and writing papers and abstracts (and reviewing others' research papers and the like).  It really isn't so bad.

From what I have observed around here, elementary schools have optional science fairs.  I like it at the elementary level.  The kids are super excitable and the experiments should be easy enough for the parent to guide the kid (instead of doing it for the kid).

For all of you parents freaking out about science fair, it's really not that difficult.  Here's the run down for what should be included for a good science fair project:

Objective/Purpose(s) - Why did you do this experiment?  Why do you think it's important?  Where did you get your idea?  This is where you state your hypothesis (your educated guess/prediction) on what you think would happen when you did this experiment and why you thought that would happen.

Materials and Methods - What supplies did you use for your experiment?  How did you set up your experiment?  Where was it set up (closet, outside, sunshine/shade, up high, on the grass/level table, etc.)?  How long did your experiment last?  What did you do?

This is a great place for pictures of your experimental set-up.  Before anything begins experimentally, snap a few pictures so everyone gets the bigger picture of what you are doing.  Be as clear as possible.  You want others to be able to repeat your experiment (and hopefully your results!).

Results - What happened?  This is a matter-of-fact rundown of what went down with your experiment.  No need for interpretation here.  Just show what happened through pictures, pretty graphs, detailed descriptions.

Discussions - Why did the experiment turn out the way it did?  This is where your interpretation happens.  Support your statements and results by ideas others have shown or imperfections in your experiment and why certain things happened/didn't happen (ie. our 3 banana balloon experiment grew mold, so we don't know if the balloon could have grown bigger).

Conclusions - What is the take away message of your experiment?  Is there anything you would do differently if given a "do-over" or a "let's investigate further" opportunity?


Presentation is a good portion of science fair.  If you can't present your project in a logical way, many people will just walk on by and not even talk to you about your cool project.

Your best bet is to use a trifold for the poster board display.  It's great because it stands up on it's own.  You can also bring your experiment set-up and/or results and place it in front of your board for show-and-tell.  This is my example trifold set-up.


Tips and pointers for science fair display:
  • You'd want to use at least 36 pt font so people can read it from a comfortable distance.
  • Use a normal font, please, at least for the content/bulk of your poster (in the real world, chose a sans serif font, like Arial).
  • Don't use too many words.  Nobody wants to read paragraphs (there's a lot of science to get to!).
  • Size up and bold the headers (ie Objective, Materials/methods, possibly use all CAPITAL letters - it's up to you or the requirements set forth by your school/organization).
    • I used colored cardstock paper to give my headers an outline boarder back in my science fair day.  If you chose this route, please select complimentary/corresponding colors.
  • Bullets and/or numbered lists can be your best friend when it comes to organization.
  • At the elementary school level, most of the presentation will be methods and materials.  It's important for kids to learn what they did and how to express that logically in a step-by-step manner.  I gave it a whole 1/3 of the poster board.  Feel free to adjust as you see fit.  Most of my scientific posters have the materials/methods starting in the bottom of column 1, and the results start in the bottom of column 2 and go to top of column 3.
  • Possibly bold your main purpose and the main conclusion as your BAM! take away message.

Now for some fun science fair ideas:
  • Banana/balloon experiment -try the experiment in different areas (sunlight vs closet, warm vs fridge), maybe try to compare a decomposing banana to a different decomposing fruit, compare different sized containers? How big did your balloon get? Which condition made the balloon expand first?
  • Race car experiment - how far does your race car go on different surfaces? Use the same ramp and car on different surfaces (ie. tile/gravel/aspalt).  Measure the differences and come up with some conclusions on why cars travel further on certain surfaces.
  • Balloon race car experiment - buy a cheap balloon race car or make one of your own.  Compare balloons of different sizes/volumes and/or how far each travels on different surfaces. Does the size or shape of your race car matter?
  • If you have time, grow your experiments, try plants:
    • Grow plants in different pots filled with different materials (soil, soil with enrichment, dirt, gravel, etc).
    • Feed your plants different liquids (water, soda water, soda, juice, etc.).
    • Grow a plant upright and a plant on its side (tipped over pot)

This list is in no way inclusive, but hopefully can spark some easy to do at home experiments.

Science Bob also has some good science fair ideas if you want to look through some of those ideas.

Also, I'd love to have (young) guest bloggers writing about their science fair projects here!  It'll be like a mini science fair.  Email me if you are interested in guest blogging.

Related Post: Keeping a science lab notebook.

Sunday, February 5, 2012

Bananas and balloons

J goes on banana kicks.  He loves them, and then he won't eat them for weeks.  He's doing the latter at the moment.

So, we decided to make an experiment from one of our rotting bananas.

I took the idea from the book, The Everything Kids' Science Experiments Book, which happens to be my favorite Christmas present I received this year.  Don't worry, I have a review in the works to give some opinions on this book and twists to toddlers and preschoolers (it's geared for 8+).  I hope to finish this review in the near future.

Anyways, it's a fairly easy set-up.  You mash up a very ripe (think brown) banana, stick it in a bottle (we used one of our many 20oz soda bottles), pop a balloon over the top of the bottle, and document the process.  The book recommends putting it outside in a sunny place to expedite the process.  However, we live in an apartment complex with a lot of boys who have potential of screwing up well planned science experiments...and it's not really "warm" outside, mid-60s at best.  Our apartment has been ~70 deg during the day, but the balloon hasn't been exposed to sun.

Peeling the bananas

Mashing it up with a spoon

We documented through pictures and also by measuring tape once the balloon inflated enough to measure:

Monday 1/30: Set-up the experiment



Tuesday 1/31: no noticeable change in balloon


But, there's some icky changes going on with the banana (there was some bubbly action)



Wednesday 2/1: balloon is a little more full, but still sad looking



Thursday 2/2: Balloon stands up!  J is excited that science is working.


And take a look at that gross banana mush.



Friday, 2/3: Began balloon measuring - 5 cm


More bubbly grossness in the banana mush:



Saturday 2/4: 5.2 cm



Sunday 2/5: 5.2 cm (no change, no new pic)

I'll leave the bottle alone for a week and report back next weekend.

What's going on?  As the banana decomposes/decays, it's releasing gas which wants to escape the bottle but is trapped by the balloon.  It puts pressure on the balloon, causing it to inflate.

Our Personal Extensions:
Trying this experiment during the summer inside and out (assuming we find a safe "sunny" location).  We'll compare them to each other and to the growth of the balloon during the winter inside.  Maybe we'll try one at the same time in the fridge too.  Stay tuned for another banana and balloons post over the summer.

We'll also try a smaller bottle and/or more bananas for hopefully a more dramatic response.